Anthony Amobi: Will Jake Arrieta ever figure it out?

On Sunday, Jake Arrieta started on the mound for the Orioles. One would have thought after a successful spring training, he would finally figure it out after several seasons in the majors.

From the looks of things, he still may not have. After his performance against the Los Angeles Dodgers, Arrieta was again optioned to Triple-A Norfolk for seemingly the umpteenth time in the last couple of seasons.

Sitting in the stands Sunday, I wondered how a guy who looks like your prototypical power pitcher at 6-foot-4 cannot get it together. Arrieta has been less than mediocre in his young major league career. He has 20-24 record, a 5.40 ERA and 0.5 WAR in parts of four seasons with the Orioles according to Baseball Reference.

By now, most Oriole fans know that he was one of the members of former general manager Andy MacPhail’s vaunted cavalry from several seasons back that was supposed to get the franchise out of a decade-plus losing rut.

The Orioles did finally dig themselves out the basement and ended up in the playoffs in 2012. However, Arrieta was absent from it mostly by his own doing.

On Sunday, he looked like an ace the first few frames; sadly, in final innings of his start, Arrieta became unglued. The problems that have plagued him throughout his career - walks, giving up hits at inopportune times and not trusting his stuff - played a large part in costing the Orioles a series sweep.

Fans know that Arrieta is talented and has the stuff in his arsenal to succeed. The question is, when does it come together?

Could his problems be mechanical? Mental? A lack of confidence or a coherent game plan?

Manager Buck Showalter and the front office seemingly still believe in him, so he will be given every chance to succeed.

Arrieta is 27 and may be entering a crossroad in his career, but it would not make sense to dump or trade him as of yet.

There’s a pitcher in the organization that has been down the same road that Arrieta is on right now: Chris Tillman.

Tillman was another highly regarded pitcher who had his shares of ups and downs during his major league career. He was another guy who often shuffled between the majors and minors. However, last season, Tillman finally delivered on his promise and had a 9-3 record with a 2.93 ERA in 15 starts.

Now, Tillman - for now - is a mainstay in the rotation and part of the franchise’s future.

Can the same be said for Arrieta? Scouts seem to love him, and ESPN’s Jerry Crasnick quipped this week that if the Orioles offered him up in trade or released him, “I know 29 teams that would be takers.”

Arrieta has the potential to go far in the majors, but developing pitchers is a hard task to accomplish in any organization.

At this point, whether or not that can happen depends on him.

Anthony Amobi blogs about the Orioles at Oriole Post. His observations about the O’s appear as part of’s season-long initiative of welcoming guest bloggers to our site. All opinions expressed are those of the guest bloggers, who are not employed by but are just as passionate about their baseball as our roster of writers.

blog comments powered by Disqus