The Orioles hold an $11 million option on Reynolds' contract for 2013 that includes a $500,000 buyout. It wasn't long ago that the thought of picking up that option seemed absurd, and I still have my doubts, but it's worth debating. Reynolds has 21 home runs and 65 RBIs. He leads the club with 70 walks and ranks among the leaders with 25 doubles and a .348 on-base percentage. His 145 strikeouts are 11 fewer than Davis' total. The question is, what value do you place on a 20-plus home run hitter who offers plus-defense at first base and is one of the most popular guys in the clubhouse - a gamer with a great sense of humor? He's only hitting .228, and his bat was in deep freeze for the first half of the season. Consistency isn't one of his tools. Reynolds hit nine homers from Aug. 31-Sept. 8. He hasn't launched one since then, but he's always a threat to go on another long-ball binge. The Orioles apparently want him back in 2013, which wasn't the case in spring training and over the first few months of the season. They could decline his option and negotiate a lower deal. Reynolds could become a free agent and seek a better deal, though he's perfectly happy in Baltimore. Machado is making a solid case for entering spring training next year as the starting third baseman, with shortstop his eventual move once J.J. Hardy is gone. He's played every inning at third since the Orioles purchased his contract on Aug. 9, and he's committed only two errors in that span. One of them was bogus, but it counts. The Orioles have made only 12 errors during that stretch, and their fielding percentage leads the American League. In one of the strangest twists to the season, they're now regarded as being good defensively, and all it took was moving Reynolds to first, inserting a 20-year-old minor league shortstop at third and putting Nate McLouth in left. Do the Orioles cross the infield corners off their winter shopping list and focus more on the rotation and second base? For that matter, do they ignore left field and hope that, just maybe, Nolan Reimold can stay healthy and at least platoon with McLouth?